Cost-Effective Alternative to Impact-Resistant Roof Shingles

Summary

  • Asphalt shingles need to be flexible to withstand impacts from hail and debris, but they tend to dry out and become brittle with age. This means they can crack when flying objects hit your roof.
  • Impact-resistant shingles are made with reinforced materials that absorb shock better than regular shingles. They hold up much better to hail, but they’re expensive—and require a full tear-off.
  • Third-party testing shows that applying Roof Maxx can reduce hail denting by up to 24%. It can also help prevent mold growth and heat loss through the roof.
  • You can expect to pay up to $30,000+ for a roof replacement with IR shingles. Roof Maxx costs up to 80% less and lets you get more use out of the shingles you already have.

Hail, wind, and flying debris can take a serious toll on your roof and shingles, especially if they’re already brittle from years of exposure to the elements. Impact-resistant (IR) shingles are often marketed as an upgrade that can hold up better to hail strikes and other weather-related issues like high winds.

The only catch? They’re up to or over 25% more expensive than asphalt shingles, and that high price tag doesn’t typically include the cost of labor that comes with putting them on.

Roof Maxx is a cost-effective alternative that can make your current asphalt shingles more durable for a fraction of the price. Get to know the features and benefits of each option below in this article from our team of home exterior experts.

Hailstones melting on an asphalt shingle roof after a storm
Hailstones melting on an asphalt shingle roof after a storm

First: The Science of Asphalt Shingles

Asphalt shingles are made from petrochemical oils that make them flexible and pliable. You should be able to bend a new shingle in half without any granules popping off or cracking the shingle itself—in fact, that’s a great way to test shingle strength if you’re ever shopping in person.

But like fresh tar on pavement, asphalt doesn’t stay flexible forever. Constant exposure to the elements will dry out your shingles over time and cause them to become brittle. That’s bad news if you live in an area where impact damage is a problem.

Here’s how hail and other debris can damage your shingles when they strike the surface:

  • The faster and harder the impact, the more kinetic energy is produced.
  • If the shingle is still flexible, the energy gets spread out evenly across the surface.
  • If it’s brittle, the energy gets concentrated into a smaller area, which intensifies the hit and causes more damage.

Roofs that are over 20 years old often have dozens of dents or shallow holes from impacts over the years that extend all the way down into the underlayment. All those little divots and depressions can also trap water from storms and create the perfect breeding ground for mold.

Impact-resistant architectural shingles on the roof of a customer's home.
Impact-resistant architectural shingles on the roof of a customer's home.

What Are Impact-Resistant Roof Shingles?

IR shingles contain extra layers of reinforced material that allow them to absorb the shock of impacts and resist other forms of damage more effectively.

On the surface, they look the same as your run-of-the-mill asphalt shingle, but it’s what’s inside that really counts:

  • Materials: IR shingles are typically made from a combination of modified asphalt, rubber, fiberglass, and/or polymers (plastics). This creates a thicker shingle with more material that can absorb hits without denting or cracking.
  • Lab Testing: Products are given a rating of 1-4 on the UL 2218 impact scale based on how well they respond to simulated hail. Class 1 offers the least protection, while Class 4 offers the most.
  • Installation: Installing IR shingles over existing shingles is never recommended and can actually violate the warranty or building codes. You’ll typically need a total tear-off before putting them on.

The main trade-off is weight. Because IR shingles are so much heavier, they can actually put strain on the framing if your roof is already compromised (unless you reinforce it first).

The Benefits of IR Shingles

Most homeowners who choose IR shingles aren’t solely looking to make their roof more resistant to hail or flying debris during storms. They’re looking for the overall boost in durability that comes with installing stronger, long-lasting shingles instead.

We’re talking about benefits like:

  • Little to no granule loss as the roof ages.
  • A lower risk for cracking, warping, or melting in extreme temperatures.
  • Lower insurance rates or a better chance of keeping coverage in high-risk areas.
  • Stronger resistance to wind shear and storm damage, including gusts up to 130 MPH.

Advantages like these are clear, but how much you personally stand to gain is another story. If you end up paying more than you can afford or more than you’ll save over time, you probably aren’t getting a good deal.

Two Roof Maxx technicians spray our soy-based solution onto a customer's roof.
Two Roof Maxx technicians spray our soy-based solution onto a customer's roof.

Why You Should Consider Roof Maxx Instead

Roof Maxx lets you get more life out of your existing asphalt shingles for up to 80% less than what it would cost to install IR shingles. The treatment process takes less than an afternoon, so it won’t disrupt your life—and it’s scientifically proven to make your roof more resistant to hail.

But protection from impact damage is just the start. Roof Maxx is the better deal because you get more value for your money even though it costs less.

How Roof Maxx Works

Roof Maxx is made from soy methyl ester—an oil extracted from soybeans grown by farmers right here in the US. It works by re-infusing dried-out asphalt shingles with oils so they can flex, bend, and absorb shock from impacts again. 

The treatment process is very straightforward:

  1. You give us a call at 1-800-ROOFMAXX
  2. Your closest dealer will chat with you about your needs.
  3. A Roof Maxx dealer will inspect your roof in person to ensure you’re a good fit.
  4. We’ll provide a clear, upfront quote that details the full cost and what you’ll receive.
  5. The dealer will schedule your treatment on a date and time that works for you. 
  6. A technician will spray Roof Maxx evenly across the surface of your shingles when they arrive.
  7. The solution will begin to soak deep down into your shingles around the granules right away.
  8. Once the oil makes contact with the asphalt, it will begin to soften it and make it flexible again.

The surface of your roof will be dry to the touch within about 30 minutes. The effects will become increasingly pronounced over the first 72 hours.

The Benefits Of Roof Maxx

A flexible shingle is always more durable, so the main benefit is a longer-lasting, more resilient roof. In fact, third-party testing at Ohio State University (OSU) showed that Roof Maxx effectively improved overall durability and permeability while also reducing the size of dents from hail by up to 24%.

Having your roof treated can also:

  • Reduce undesirable heat transfer through the roof, boosting energy efficiency.
  • Extend the life of your roof by up to 15 years (with repeated treatments at regular intervals)
  • Help you save money and put off early roof replacement until you absolutely need it. 
  • Make your roof look like it’s new again!

Roof Maxx also contains a natural fungicide that helps prevent mold, mildew, and algae from forming on your roof. You don’t just get protection—you get performance, savings, and peace of mind, all in one eco-friendly treatment you can feel good about using.

Freshly installed IR shingles on a chalet home here in the US.
Freshly installed IR shingles on a chalet home here in the US.

How Much Do IR Shingles Cost?

When you have IR shingles installed, you’re paying for so much more than just the product, including labor, waste disposal, and any other unexpected repair needs that crop up along the way. Here’s a rough overview of what most homeowners can expect to pay: 

  • Labor and Materials: $3.00 to $7.00 per square foot
  • Removing the Old Roof: $3 to $5 per square foot
  • New Underlayment: $0.10 to $0.80 per square foot 
  • New Drip Edge: $1.50 to $3.00 per linear foot
  • Total cost: $10,000 to $30,000+ depending on roof size and complexity.
  •  

You should factor in any potential savings on insurance, annual maintenance, and repairs before you make your decision, because that’s where you’ll see the most benefit long-term.

How Much Does Roof Maxx Cost?

Roof Maxx is a one and done treatment—but let’s talk about what that actually means. You pay a flat rate for everything with no hidden fees or incidentals along the way.

Here’s how it typically shakes out:

  • Labor and Materials: Bundled into the price.
  • Incidentals: None, since there’s nothing to remove or replace.
  • Total cost: Typically comes in at around 80% less than the cost of a full roof replacement.

You’ll get the most value from Roof Maxx if you schedule your first treatment when your roof is 5 to 10 years old, then repeat it every five years. But don’t let these guardrails stop you—we’ve seen the product help people with much older roofs put off early replacement even when they thought all was lost.

ProTip: Ask about our roof tune-up package if you think you might need a few minor repairs. We can often include them in your quote and take care of them before your treatment.

One of our Roof Maxx dealers finishes a spraying job at a customer's home.
One of our Roof Maxx dealers finishes a spraying job at a customer's home.

Protect Your Roof Without Paying for a New One

When hail, high winds, and other weather events threaten your home, you have two main options: impact-resistant shingles or Roof Maxx. Both can help make your roof more durable to hail, debris, high winds, and rain, but only Roof Maxx does it for a fraction of the cost.

Before you spend so much money on a total roof replacement, give us a call. You have nothing to lose and you could save thousands in the process. Find a dealer in your area now for a free quote.

Share this post
Facebook
LinkedIn
X
Reddit
Tumblr
Threads
Email
Print
Picture of Georgios Karakitsios
Georgios Karakitsios
"George Karakitsios owns the website and marketing technology behind Roof Maxx. He has spent more than 12 years building web experiences for homeowners and Roof Maxx customers"
Stay ahead of home repairs and protect your investment
Subscribe now for expert roofing and maintenance tips straight to your inbox!

Five Year Transferable Warranty

With our five-year, transferable warranty, you’ll enjoy the peace of mind that your roof and entire home are protected.

Stay ahead of home repairs and protect your investment
Subscribe now for expert roofing and maintenance tips straight to your inbox!